1. According to the Mind/Brain Identity Theory, do mentalistic terms

1. According to the Mind/Brain Identity Theory, do mentalistic terms like “belief” or “pain” compete with physical terms like “neuronal impulse” or “synaptic cleft”? Should we aim to preserve the use of both mental terms and physical terms? Why or why not? 

2. Reconstruct Descartes’ first argument for dualism. Is it valid? If not, why not? (Are the premises true? Is the conclusion true? Explain your answers.) 

3. Descartes’ first and second arguments for dualism both appeal to the same principle: namely, Leibniz’s Law. Will the same objection suffice to undermine both? If not, why not? 

4. What is a propositional attitude? Give three examples that aren’t discussed above. 

5. Consider the following set of propositions: (1) “Linda remembers receiving an autograph from Muhammad Ali.” (2) “Linda does not remember receiving an autograph from Cassius Clay.” • Do these propositions contain any reference to propositional attitudes? If so, which? • Do these propositions attribute any properties to objects? If so, which objects? • What conclusion, if any, can you derive from these two propositions? (Does it follow that Muhammad Ali and Cassius Clay are different people? 

6. Descartes says that he can conceive of himself being a disembodied spirit (that is, having a mind but not a body). What does conceiving of something mean? Does Descartes’ claim entail that it is possible for him to be a disembodied spirit? (See discussion of conceivability and possibility in Chapter 8.) 

7. Is a statue identical with the stone it is made of? Is an organism identical with the collection of cells in its body? Can Leibniz’s Law be used to show that either of these claims of identity is false? 

8. In the Sixth Meditation, Descartes argues that he is essentially a thinking thing. An essential property of a thing is a property that the thing must have if it is to exist. Could Descartes be deprived of thought and still be Descartes? Could Descartes have been born without the capacity of thought and still be Descartes? If Descartes can’t doubt that he thinks, is that enough to show that Descartes is essentially a thinking thing? 

9. It was suggested in this chapter that we understand causality best when there is a physical signal that passes from cause to effect (the electricity example). However, the fact that “absences” sometimes cause suggests that causality need not involve a physical signal. For example, suppose a patient dies because his doctor fails to give him medicine. There is no “physical signal” between the doctor and patient in this case, but there is causation. Does this point solve the objection to dualism that concerns the nature of causality?

10. Would the discovery of perfect correlations between certain mental events and physical events (say, between experiences of pain and c-fiber firings) be evidence against dualism? Why or why not? 

11. What are the two central arguments that advocates of the Mind/Brain Identity thesis typically appeal to when defending their position? 

12. Why might someone doubt that the Principle of Uniformity is a surefire guide to which theories we should pursue? Do you think this skepticism is well-founded, or is it just another example of philosophers’ penchant for “radical doubt”? 

13. Suppose we observe a perfect correlation between some mental property (like feeling pain) and some physical property (like having one’s c-fibers fire). Apply the Surprise Principle (Chapter 3) to see whether this observation strongly favors the identity theory over dualism. 

14.In the passage from Principles of Natural Philosophy quoted in this chapter, Newton defends the Principle of Parsimony by saying that “Nature does nothing in vain.” Is this idea consistent with what we now know about natural selection (Chapter 6)? 

15. The Principle of Parsimony is often thought to be relevant to the question of whether God exists. Formulate and evaluate an argument for atheism that makes use of this principle. 

16. On the companion website, the psychologist U. T. Place defends the identity theory, but does not mention the Principle of Parsimony. He does so by describing a situation in which the correlation between two events justifies the conclusion that the two are identical. Evaluate Place’s argument.

17. What would it mean for something to be a first cause without being God? What would it mean for something to necessarily exist without being God 

18. Aquinas seems to commit the Birthday Fallacy when he argues that, if every natural event has a cause, then there must be one “first cause.” Why is this line of reasoning fallacious? Can you think of another example of the Birthday Fallacy? 

19. Why does Aquinas think that it is “inconceivable” that the world is infinitely old? Do you think his argument is plausible? Why or why not? 

20. Why, if at all, do you think it might be helpful to reflect on unsuccessful arguments for the existence of God? Explain your answer. 

21. Which of the four arguments discussed above do you find most convincing? Why? Problems for Further Thought 

1 I formulated Aquinas’s proofs by having him talk about objects that exist in “nature” (in “the natural world”). What does “nature” include? Does it include just the things we can see or hear or touch or taste or smell? 

2 In discussing Aquinas’s third proof, I talked about Charlie the atom as an example of a thing that is both eternal and contingent. Could something exist that is both necessary and noneternal? It would exist at some time in each possible world, though it would not exist at all times in the actual world. Can you give an example of such a thing? 

3 I criticized Aquinas’s third argument by discussing numbers, which I claimed exist necessarily. Can the argument be reformulated so that this objection no longer applies? 

4 I criticized Aquinas’s fourth argument by discussing “maximum stupidity.” Can Aquinas reply to this objection by claiming that stupidity is just the absence of intelligence?

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

patient file

Your final project for this course will be a patient record analysis. You will apply the knowledge of anatomy, physiology, and pharmacology that you have developed during this course in a thorough review of existing patient information in the Final Project Patient File. Specifically, you will review a patient’s history

610 6-1 Discussion: Improve, Part Two—Mitigating Unwanted Consequences

 The Essential Workplace Conflict Handbook. Including the IMPROVE Supplementary Document. Next, in your initial post, address the following: • In what ways do you perceive the Improve phase as being informed by the other phases of DMAIC that you have worked with in the course thus far? • How can

Code of conduct

 For this assignment, Write a paper about employee codes of conduct using information from your textbook and at least two other scholarly sources. First, research employee codes of ethics, especially for the medical field. Next, find some examples of employee codes of ethics from medical facilities and choose the one

Human Growth and Development

Scenario: Simon Whitaker is 42 years old and has suffered from mental illness since his late teens. He lives in a flat in a large housing estate. He lost his job as a warehouse cleaner after he was admitted to hospital the last time he became ill, two years ago.

Exporting Security

Write a 2 page argumentative essay on the links provided below. Link 1: https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/SSQ/Book-Reviews/Article/1292320/exporting-security-international-engagement-security-cooperation-and-the-changi/ Link 2:https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1049&context=nwc-review Link 3: https://digital-commons.usnwc.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1049&context=nwc-review #Exporting #Security

Organizational culture and values

 Details: Prepare a 10-minute presentation (10-15 slides, not including title or reference slide) on organizational culture and values. Describe how alignment between the values of an organization and the values of the nurse impact nurse engagement and patient outcomes. Discuss how an individual can use effective communication techniques to overcome

Document Analysis

Document Analysis (5% – c. 500 words) Primary sources are writings that were produced by individuals or groups at the time of the historical events or issues that they deal with. A number of such documents have been placed on Blackboard, organized by course unit. This assignment requires you to

M3D1: Big Data

The discussion will examine the social interaction of participants regarding an issue or situation and its impact on research data. This discussion addresses the following module outcomes: •MO1: Become familiar with the process of conducting marketing research methods and research tools •MO2: Review the process marketers use for identifying and

Case Study 1 and 2 Pneumonia and Addison diseases

Review the case study and answer all questions with a scholarly response using APA and include 2 scholarly references. Answer both case studies on the same document and upload 1 document to Moodle. Case Studies will be uploaded to Moodle and put through TURN-It-In (anti-Plagiarism program) Turn it in Score

Should schools ban unhealthy snack machines?

 Your outline should include: An explanation of the controversial issue, why is it controversial? Identify which position or side you will take in your paper, and explain why. If you don’t agree with the position you are taking discuss how this could affect your argument on the topic. If you

The Outcome of Inequality of Wealth and Income

Research Topic: Submit an idea for a research study based on a business/economic problem. • Write the title of the study. • Explain your overarching aim for the study. • What is the problem? • What is the significance of it? • Draft at least two research questions. Due 1/27

“practice of professional engineering”

1. “practice of professional engineering” means any act of planning, designing, composing, evaluating, advising, reporting, directing or supervising that requires the application of engineering principles and concerns the safeguarding of life, health, property, economic interests, the public welfare or the environment, or the managing of any such act; (“exercice de

Curriculum Development and Evaluation

 Learning Materials: Keating, S. B. (2011). Curriculum development and evaluation in nursing (2nd ed.). New York: Springer. (Chapter 13) Books are on website Vital Source user name is sred9196@yahoo.com, the password is Bungalow9@ • Exercise #1: Address an educational need among nursing staff at a health care agency. In the

Epidemiology and Surveillance

Research the public health agency in Chicago, IL and develop a presentation on its structure, response capabilities, surveillance tools, and role in emergency management. In your response, include a description of the community served by the department (Chicago), its emergency response structure, surveillance systems that are used at hospitals, biohazard

General Psychology Application

 General Psychology Application Essay Over the course of the class, we have discussed a number of different psychological concepts and theories. For your paper you will be asked to connect a real life experience or observation with a concept or theory from lecture and/or your textbook. Your assignment should include

Issues and Trends in Curriculum Development

 Learning Materials: • Iwasiw, C., Goldenberg, D., & Andrusyszyn, M. (2009). Curriculum development in nursing education (2nd ed.). Boston: Jones & Bartlett. (Chapters 13 and 14) • Keating, S. B. (2011). Curriculum development and evaluation in nursing (2nd ed.). New York: Springer. (Chapters 16 and 17) PowerPoint • Chapter 13

Foundation of Nursing Module 2.1 ( Discussion)

Module 2.1 – Discussion Nursing Theories and Theorists Instructions: After reading the assigned chapters, please post two discussion questions based on the readings along with your answers to the following questions: Did any of the theories or theorist influence your own personal theory of nursing; and consequently, your own view